Commit Graph
2 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
shadow-testandClaude Opus 5 2de00b3c55 Fix review findings: secrets in snapshots, URL spoofing, migration data loss
Adversarial review of the branch produced findings across four areas.
This addresses them, plus the Windows CI environment.

Secrets. commit_container_snapshot baked the container's full env into
the per-project snapshot image, so the shared OAuth token — and the AWS
keys, git token and gateway master key — outlived revocation and were
readable via docker inspect. Verified against Engine 29.6 that a commit
body's config merges over the container's: keys cannot be dropped but
can be overwritten, so all of them now commit as KEY=. clear_claude_token
additionally rewrites images from earlier builds and reports honestly
when a tag could not be rewritten.

The recommendation to move the token out of env entirely was not taken,
with reasoning: apiKeyHelper is a different auth method that outranks
CLAUDE_CODE_OAUTH_TOKEN rather than a transport for it, and no
file-based delivery exists. The durable exposure — the image — is what
is closed here. Separately noted, not fixed: entrypoint.sh captures the
token into the scheduler's .env inside the persisted volume.

URL spoofing. Three call sites reached openUrl with container-controlled
strings, one of which the review missed (the WebLinksAddon handler).
The sign-in URL was scraped from container output with a longest-match
tie-break and no userinfo check, so claude.ai@evil.tld rendered as
"claude.ai…" in a truncating element. There is now one sanitizer in
front of every sink — scheme allowlist, no userinfo, C0/C1 and quote
rejection, host allowlist for the sign-in case, first-match — and the
origin renders un-truncated. The toast is keyed so a changed URL
remounts, closing a bait-and-switch where the user read one URL and
clicked another.

Migration. The rollback pin was best-effort: a tag failure was logged
and the migration continued past remove_container, after which the
final commit overwrote the only copy of the old system layer. It now
aborts before anything destructive and reads the tag back. /var was
destroyed while the ordinary recreate path preserves it — making the
"safe" alternative to Reset more destructive than Reset's alternative;
data-bearing subtrees are now detected and disclosed in the pre-flight
rather than copied, since tarring a live database onto a different
base's packages is a corruption risk. resume_migration now verifies the
migration-state label instead of reporting success for a container that
never swapped. dismiss actually resolves the record rather than leaving
the feature permanently refusing to migrate. Start and Reset are guarded
while a migration is live.

Lifecycle. The gateway no longer publishes on 0.0.0.0 — bind address and
advertised URL are derived together so they cannot drift. Disabling it
now stops it. App exit runs teardown concurrently under a budget with a
visible shutting-down state instead of blocking for minutes. Auto-starts
retry when Docker is not up yet, and the polling-recovery path now
reconciles, so interrupted migrations are still recovered. Auth-bridge
forwards are capped, closing a container-driven fd exhaustion.

Windows CI. build-windows failed on this branch with "linker link.exe
not found". The runner had no MSVC build tools and the workflow assumed
a hand-provisioned machine, so a bare runner registers, accepts jobs and
fails at link time after downloading the whole crate graph. The job now
installs the VC++ workload when vswhere cannot find it, matching how it
already conditionally installs Rust and Node.

192 Rust tests, 274 frontend tests, both builds clean, zero warnings.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-09 19:35:39 -07:00
shadow-testandClaude Opus 5 d42b741337 Migrate a project onto a new base image without losing its volumes
Projects were pinned to the image they were first created from. Both
create paths preferred triple-c-snapshot-<id>:latest whenever it
existed, and container_needs_recreation compared the container's live
image against the triple-c.image label — which create_container wrote
from the same image it created from. A tautology that could never fire.
The only escape was Reset, which calls remove_project_volumes and
destroys the login, skills and transcripts.

Measured consequences on this host: real projects are missing socat (so
the auth bridge cannot tunnel) and bubblewrap (so sandbox mode does not
work), plus Mission Control and triple-c-sso-refresh, and sit 61
packages behind the base including ca-certificates, openssl and curl.

Detection. create_container now writes triple-c.base-image-id (the image
ID, not RepoDigests, which local-built and custom images do not have)
and triple-c.create-image. container_needs_recreation takes the expected
create-image and compares against the latter, so the check means
something. base-image-id is deliberately NOT compared: a base bump would
otherwise silently recreate from the snapshot, consuming the "you should
migrate" signal without migrating. Staleness is surfaced, never acted on
automatically.

Migration keeps the volumes. /home/claude and ~/.claude are volumes and
the image's copy is seed-only — permanently masked after first mount —
so the login, ~/.claude.json, skills, transcripts, scheduler tasks, SSH
keys, cargo, uv, ruff and Claude Code itself re-attach untouched. Only
root-level state is rebuilt: apt packages are replayed against the new
base rather than copied, so no stale libc is dragged forward, and
/usr/local, /opt and the non-bind-mounted parts of /workspace are copied
verbatim with tar --skip-old-files so they can never clobber a newer
base binary.

docker diff is not used: on a snapshot-derived container it reports only
changes since the last commit. Raw image-vs-image diffing is filtered
through dpkg ownership because it otherwise lies — 8,677 raw path
differences on a real project reduced to 2 genuinely user-authored
files, both loose /workspace-root files.

Crash safety. snapshot:latest keeps pointing at the old image until the
final commit, so any crash before it self-heals on next start. Later
crashes are caught by reconcile_project_statuses. The rollback pin is a
docker tag: 0.057s and 0 bytes. Rollback restores the system layer only
— volumes are never touched — and the UI says so rather than implying a
time machine.

Fixes an infinite recreation loop shipped with the MCP removal. docker
commit propagates labels to the image, so a container created from a
snapshot inherited its non-empty triple-c.mcp-fingerprint and the
one-shot shim recreated it again on every start, forever. Lineage labels
are now always written explicitly.

Documents the second, separate bug this uncovered: Dockerfile changes
under /home/claude never reach an existing project, migration or not,
because the volume masks them. Anything that must stay upgradable
belongs in /usr/local/bin or /opt, or must be seeded by entrypoint.sh.

145 Rust tests, 227 frontend tests, both builds clean.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-09 18:19:12 -07:00