Episode: 969 Title: HPR0969: The Crivins Audiocast Source: https://hub.hackerpublicradio.org/ccdn.php?filename=/eps/hpr0969/hpr0969.mp3 Transcribed: 2025-10-08 05:51:39 --- ΒΆΒΆ This is Michael. I have decided to listen to a podcast that he has about three programs. This is the one of Kevin and Gordon, on the east side of Engelska. The one with Skotska accent. Podcasts are... Crevans brought to you by Hansen Studio. We don't do DRM. Hello and welcome to season 10, episode 1 of Crevans. Otherwise known as episode 10 of Crevans. It's a common mistake to make with a lot of podcasts these days. They're all going... They're seasons. But anyway, we're on episode 10. And as usual, this is actually a more regular episode that's myself. And Kevin, again. Hello, hello, and how are we doing out there tonight, Gordon? Yeah, I'm all right. It's an interesting Wi-Fi stories. We won't... We won't bother people about it. So, we're going to start off... I'm going to use all sort of news and then a discussion and things. So, the first story was something that I saw last week. I think it was last week. And I just thought this was brilliant. It's a brilliant idea. It's... Someone has made a version of Tron, a little game Tron, that's made entirely in JavaScript. It's something like 200 and something K. It's tiny. It's genius. It's just brilliant. I found it rather hard because I'm not used to keyboard controls. And it's quite fast as well for the small screen. But I just think this is genius. And they did a version of Tetris before that. And they're really in JavaScript as well. So, yeah, I thought I would have been mentioning that to start with. Yeah, it's a nice wee topic to start with, actually. I didn't notice it. It's an identity that people were talking about. But I kind of logged in. And they would have to be through it. And I'm seeing all this, you know, 200 bytes. And 140 bytes and one would take. Are we talking about that? I actually thought it was a talk about retro gaming. So, to be honest, I didn't realise it was actually talking about tiny games that I don't know just now. So, you actually went and tried them, but didn't you? I haven't tried them yet. Yeah, I tried Tetris. And the way they've done it, unless I've just not played along enough, it's all a little pound cymbals or harsh cymbals. That's what's fallen down as a blocks. And you get a single block and it's on or the two blocks, which is two side by side. But you can't seem to... There's no other advanced shapes. I've none of the analysts for like L shapes and things. So, it's not really that time consuming. You can't put them around or something. So, it's not great, but the throne one is actually quite impressive. The black screen with a white line that moves rather fast. Considering the size of the screen you've got to play with. And you die if you have the edge. But yeah, the idea for what they did was they said, they had to be sort of a competition or sort of... Yeah, I suppose it'd be a competition to see who could create a game and the least lines of code. And I just thought that was a genius for what they've managed to do with that level, you know? Yeah, excellent. I'll need to have a wee look at that. Hopefully we'll be good to see if they actually have more of these released. It's amazing to see what people can actually do with just such a little amount of code. It's utterly brilliant. The one thing I'm assuming with Tetris is the old tune we love so much. Now, I'm assuming they had that down to our T. Yes. Yeah. The bush. There's no audio at all. And any of these... I don't know if I'll do it. It did not come through for me. But no, there's no audio. It's just a little bit of code. Yeah. It's good. I mean, it does show you what is... Actually, you could see yourself spending a bit of time in the Tron one just to pass some time. Tetris is more of an experiment. But Tron really is worth checking out. And we'll put the link in the show notes and then you'll find a link to Tetris and that there as well. Chances are they'll probably do a lot of stuff that's quite kind of cool. But yeah, it's cool. Oh, yes. Always nice to have a wee bit of past time. And I must admit, I'm one of these guys that see if anybody ever sees identical. I've written a new app to a new game for the Android phone. But it's not on the market yet. So I want to try it. I'm like, yeah, me, me. So I've got a bunch of these half-finished games on my phones. They argued. I like them just to try it. Just something different. Oh, and on to our next wee bit here. And there's one's regarding Wi-Fi. Now, I don't think you can get too many hardcore, just regarding, or stressy, open-source unfriendly than Texas, a state of Texas in the USA. They seem to not be too keen to take up the Linux cores. And a while ago, they were trying to have a real campaign to more or less tell people it was going to be illegal to have open Wi-Fi. And if they were unprotected, then, you know, they were breaking the law blabla. They would just scale monthly. There was no law. It was just utter nonsense. And after a group kind of set up saying, this is no law, trying to become a bit more public. They suddenly realized that we're back in town. However, on one of the news articles we've got today, the Australian police don't seem to have learned from their mistakes. And they are doing the same thing. So the official announcement is, Detective Superintendent Brian Hayes said police have identified a large number of homes and businesses within the Great Brisbane area with wireless connections that are not secure or have limited protection. These people may as well put their bank account details, passwords, and personal details are billboard at the side of the highway. Now, this is just utter nonsense. Personally, I do have my password, my network password protected. But to go to that extreme, you just scare monger as utter nonsense. Struth. This is basically a copyright thing. The authorities through lobbying by the RIE and MPAA and all of that, they basically want to avoid any possible loophole that, at the moment, if you've got an open Wi-Fi and you get some copyright infringement notice, and you say, well, look, my Wi-Fi is open. It could have been anyone. They don't like that little loophole. That's why they're determined to get people to effectively make it a social taboo to have your Wi-Fi open. And then the step further to that is actually make it illegal. So that's an offense in its own right. That means that anything that happens on that connection, they've got someone to go and slap the handcuffs on. That's what it's about. That's a hard sell to say, or it's for copyright infringement, it's for the multi-billionaires in Hollywood that want this to happen, especially since Hollywood, when my geography is not that great, but as far as I was away, Hollywood is not an Australia. It could be wrong, but it's not an Australia, it's an America. So they're using all sorts of obscure tactics to try and get people to do that. The thing is though, as much as they are square tactics, there is also an element of public service to this. A lot of computer users, especially home computer users, they are technically clueless. I mean, they know how to use Word, they know how to use Facebook and things like that, but they're technically clueless. I mean, how many times have you seen, have you heard of people who install a peer-to-peer program? And then they don't realise they're shamed and tired, they're an entire PC, rather than just one folder, because they don't know any better. And that's how you find things like blueprints for military helicopters because some contractors install the peer-to-peer program and share the whole fucking hard drive. So it's things like that, and people don't necessarily realise just how open the networks are and how open their security is. So, I mean, they could do it in a different way. They could actually go through the educating route rather than the skirmongering route, but the skirmongering route is all about copyright infringement and big Hollywood. Yes, and yeah, I personally don't think there's a problem with trying to encourage people to have wireless passwords, but like you said, there's a right way to do it and there's a wrong way, and I think this whole way about it is, it's just bullying tactics and, you know, we've come back to this a few times, but it's like that a courtroom star, or, you know, the more you tighten your grip, the more star systems fall through. And the more it becomes a point of principle after a while, the more people say you must do this. Then, you know, something that could be a very reasonable request, you're going to get people saying, well, wait a minute, it's my freedom, I'm going to choose. So just because of the way you're looking at this, I'm going to say no, which at the end of the day could actually be in theory that the person who's doing that, who's consciously saying no to this, could actually be creating themselves a bit of a security problem, not as far as them, okay, they're not going to be prosecuted, but it may well be everything that could be on their system could be got to by a decent hacker. So the other thing that they're trying to take a clamp down on as well is that cafes and pubs and things like that, anywhere that offers free Wi-Fi as an incentive to drop people in and spend time having a coffee and a burger and stuff like that. And they're trying to clamp down on that for the same reasons because of basically copyright infringement, they're basically saying that they need to be able to track everyone who uses that network and what they download. And it's hard to monitor someone if they can just join up enormously and then disappear again. Yeah, did this not happen in the UK recently? This is not going to be a president, because they tried to arrest or tried to charge a guy who owned a pub about downloaded copyright. And it actually went quite far, but then they said, well, wait a minute, this is an open network. Anybody could have done this. You can't blame the guy who owns the pub. Wasn't this not kind of a big spark of all this talk? Yeah, these issues resonate all around the world. It's like little sparks that appear in different countries and different examples. And you're right, that was one of them, the pub owner, who was targeted for that. There's a joke, basically, it's a joke. And from one walk of life from publicans to truck drivers next. Now, I want you to have a think and I'm talking about taller listeners here. The next time you download something illegally, you download copyright material. You are putting the poor truck drivers out of a job. But it makes me sad. It's just depressing me. Yeah, this was a brilliant headline from TechDoc. Wanted the truck driver who lost his job due to file sharing. And that just caught my eye. It's like, what the hell? And basically, it's the eighties again. Alcoholics are not, no, sorry, hang on. The recording industry are households of America. And the music and motion picture are households of America. One of their, I think it was the MPAA. They're not sort of known for dealing with reality. And they went on, the guy went on some show in America. Some TV show. And they tried to spin it as, it's the average person. The industry is not just the big megastars at the top. The big earning megastars. It's a whole, you know, a lot of different people who have jobs in the industry. And they tried to liken themselves to protecting the interests of the teleassessants who sell you popcorn at the fucking cinema. Not sure quite where they get royalties for movies from. And they don't even pay the fucking actor's royalties, let alone people who serve popcorn at the theatre. In this case, it was a, it went, it mentioned a truck driver who delivers like the goods, CDs and DVDs and that type of thing to the store. And losing his job due to piracy. That was the latest hook on this. I mean, the Chinese hoops all the time. And ticked up was basically saying, we want to find this guy. If I have this person, should I say, we want to find this person and talk to them. We wanted, who is this person? Get them to get in touch. We want to talk to them. So if you know of this truck driver who has lost the job due to file sharing that it's been referred to, please get in touch with ticked up. They would love to contact them. Yeah, it's now that my last Kleenex is used up and, you know, and I now realize that this fictitious driver doesn't actually exist. I feel a lot better now, yeah. This is a turn nonsense. They're taking the moral ground just by saying, of course, well, you know, if you do this, then it's not, you know, Tom Cruise or anybody else who is way up there, you are affecting their own people. You know, I mean, they're basically saying, you know, your granny is going to suffer because you downloaded that new album and you did not buy it from the shop yet. It's another nonsense. I mean, really, this goes back to, this reminds me of, I remember a while ago, they were trying to say that if you bought DVDs from the, well, as we well know with the kind of local markets, the Barras, if you bought them from then, of course, that, you know, you were immediately funding major terrorist organizations. I actually going to be in the Barras, you probably isn't too far wrong, but for quite a few, they were talking about, yes, your fundiness and your funding that. And then they did that absolutely awful knock-off Nigel advertising campaign. I mean, that was laughable. That actually made me want to go out and download copyrighted stuff. It was just awful. Do you remember that one? Yeah, I mean, first of all, for anyone who is ever thinking of visiting Scotland for a holiday or something, you've got to go to the Barras in Glasgow, make a day out at the weekend, one weekend, to go to the Barras. It's a fantastic place. It's huge. It's absolutely huge. It's a huge, free market. And the banter is brilliant. It's brilliant. I've been there a few times. And, yeah, a thorough way to enjoy it will be out. But, yeah, there is a lot of play, a lot of stalls. You can never remember where the Barras, because you go there one time, and then a week later, half of the stall owners have changed, and it's different people. But you could explain the illegal nature of a lot of the stuff they're selling and getting busted even things like that. But, yeah, they are a joke. And it's a usual OTT scare stories, because they don't really have a solid label, a legitimate thing from the consumer's point of view. They don't have the moral high ground, so they have to try and do something else to get the message across. And that's why they usually link it to anything from all the buzzwords of the day. Terrorism, you know, human trafficking, gun running, you know, drugs muggling, you know, anything that you'll, any bullshit that you're likely to believe, essentially, is what they'll try to link it to. And they just go over the top. I mean, it's the same with when they try to do stuff to quote, educate, unquote, get against drugs. You've got a referred madness. One talk of a joint, and you suddenly go mad and kill everybody. No, that doesn't happen. This is the problem. When they go so over the top, it becomes a joke. And the people who are doing it already, or who have tried it, they know it's complete box. And it's just, it's so far removed from reality that it is a joke, basically, it's a joke. If they played it a lot more, a lot more closer to reality, then they might get people buying it, but they don't, because they don't really have the moral case to be able to do that and sell it. Just going back to the bar as part, I would like to say any listener, if you knock it down weekdays, it's not open and it's not really the type of day you'd want to visit unless the market was on, and get down there early for, of course, the best bargains. So, I'm not exaggerating. If you go kind of one o'clock after lunch, forget it, most of the places I've been closed down by then. So, you want to get there as early as you can. Right, and now from one bit of moral high ground to one part where they're definitely not going to be taking the moral high ground, where, of course, Microsoft are up to the little tricks again, and they're ensuring that the European Parliament does not accept, or does not adopt open source software or open source solutions, because they have started to hand out free licenses for Microsoft programs. Now, the FSFE, that's a free software foundation for Europe, that is. There have been urgent people, urgent members of the European Parliament not to accept these, basically, because Microsoft just does not want to lose out in the customs, and it's even just going to be to the case of, right, we'll hand you some free licensing, blah, blah, blah, because they know fine well, that it is going to be effort, it is going to cost money, or goes non-costening for the software, it is costing money to get all this new system, put out new programs, obviously, need training. So, Microsoft, they're doing their usual tactics. They will try absolutely anything to make sure open source does not get into any form of public, any form of public computing, if it gets any form of publicity, it just does not want it to happen at all. Yeah, it's mind share, it's about what you know as well. So, if they've got governments and institutions, I mean, whatever government uses, that essentially leads what businesses use, because they need to take the right with government. I mean, imagine the UK government decided that, we're going to use open document format for document files now, and you know, we're going to use a proper standard. That would force Microsoft to, well, first of all, I would force them to send in the shelves, and send them to do exactly what we're talking about here, it's giving away free licenses and saying, no, you can't have that. And, you know, the whole poison campaign, you know, open source is insecure and blah, blah, blah. And if that failed, it would force them to add in their ability in Microsoft Office to support ODS, which they really don't want to do, because they want people to use their own standards. And it's all about walking, basically. If there's a bridgehead opened up with stuff like Libra Office or even Linux or BSD, but especially Libra Office, it's about what people know. They use at home often what they use at work. So if people get used to that at work, Libra Office, and they say, oh, it's free at work. I can get the exact same thing at home, and it doesn't cost a bean. I mean, the chances are they'll install in windows, but that's not the point. And that digs away the whole mindset of, you've got to have Microsoft Office to do proper office stuff. If you're finding that at work, at a government level, that you don't need that, then it starts to corrode the actual older walking, and the whole bigger cards is vulnerable. Yeah. Do you ever listen to the podcast, the Open Take Exchange with Darylinen Mark? I've heard Darylinen Mark doing a few episodes or in half of public radio, but I've not actually heard their show in the run, no. Well, they were talking about this, this exact thing, and no, this is what I want to be very careful here, right? Please, Microsoft lawyers, I am going to hear, if you're listening, right? This is not a case for legal issues, but I'm only repeating here. What they've actually been talking about was that in Africa, especially, because there's a lot of corruption in government anyway throughout the whole continent, then any country, pick a country in Africa, any time the government, pissy, right, would go in with open solutions. Darylinen Mark had said, you know, it was actually scary, immediately, Microsoft would back, whoever was the rival. Now, it didn't seem to matter to them, what exactly they were, what exactly they stood for? I mean, literally, the rival could be saying, right, we stand for cannibalism, you know, we're the cannibal party. It didn't seem to matter. They were just literally saying, right, there you go, if you say now, you are going to use Microsoft products and only Microsoft products when you get into office will fund your campaign completely. That was actually a really scary list show to listen to, that one episode, to think just, I mean, okay, this is obviously reported, but to think that they go to that extreme, just to kind of keep their product in the spotlight. To me, there's a worrying lack of morality, I mean, where do you stop? Yeah, and Microsoft didn't get where they are today by making a good product, and they didn't get where they are today by having some sort of fair competition side by side with other products, and managed to be the better one or the better value. They got there because of abuses like this. So it's no surprise. I mean, it's not so much, Microsoft has opted its old tricks again. It's just a case of Microsoft have never stopped doing these tricks. They've passed masters of that, they're well entrenched, and they do it all over the world. They've got whole departments for this, all over the world, to ensure that monopoly continues against the, the never ending match of open and transparency and standard and things like that. Yeah, I mean, it's no surprise. Really, this is nothing new for Microsoft. No, not at all, but it's kind of worrying just the fact of the levels they'll go to. I mean, but of course, you couldn't even, I can't imagine that they would even ever be a proper report on this by a proper news story because no doubt they'll be in the back pocket and then they'll be there trying to discredit the reporter or even the channel, so that isn't going to happen. Now, one of the things that has become quite a hot potato really of recently is bubbling and tracking. One of the companies that, who have been trying to make it a wee bit easier to set, I mean, you can set, anybody can set the preferences on their browser with a wee bit of tinkering to do not track. However, Mozilla in general, if you go into their preferences, it's quite obvious. Some of the, otherwise it's not. But Mozilla been working for this for their new mobile operating system, which is just in the general system, wide preferences of do not track. Now, there's only one thing that does concern me about this. You can tell, and say to your browser, to do not track. So, in other words, it does not get your cookies. Excitevers, don't get your cookies, etc, which means they shouldn't be passed on to different companies, which, you know, should mean less spam and blah, blah, blah. Right? Unfortunately, that doesn't work. It doesn't actually store up the cookies being sent out. It's everything's still there, but if you've got do not track, then the recommendation is that if you've got it set for that, that the company does not pass on or does not use on, in fact, just deletes the information tools on you. Now, there shall be a bit of a worrying thing here, because I've got to be honest, companies who do this make money of it, why, if they're not, if it's not legislation, would they even want to not pass this on? That is a thing, with the internet as services, our sites, they're free at the point of use, which the vast majority of them, and it is usually, more often than not, the price to use it free of charge, is the fact that your stuff, you've been tracked, and you've been profiled, and advertising, and all that. So that's usually the price you pay for that, to actually use the services. And, you know, I mean, could you imagine Facebook or Google of that, not tracking, it's just not going to happen, because that's, that's primarily where they get their, they get the fuel from, is from users there. So you're right, I mean, if there's no legislation to force that, even if there is legislation to force that, I doubt any of the companies would actually do it, they would do it in PR terms, they would, they would go through some process to do it, if they were forced to, and then it would be buggy, it wouldn't quite work right, there would be ways around about it, to say that, yes, we're not tracking here, but we've managed to do it this way, and just get around the legislation. It's what all criminals do, is they'll find ways around the, the laws, to keep doing what they want to do, and the profit from, while staying on the, on the letter of the law. It's a good idea, but the fact that the vast majority of the web is funded by this type of stuff, I don't think you're going to get any buy-in at all from companies, you'll get a few, you'll get some ethical ones who would do it because they believe and privacy and stuff like that if people opt out, but, you know, the vast majority will say, hey, fuck that, we'll do what we want. It's sort of like, any kind of self-regulation when there's, when there's an outcry building up, over some industries, actions about doing something. When it gets to the point that politicians are involved and start questioning the companies and the individuals involved and they start laying down hints about what they could do, usually the first thing that comes out of the company's mouth says or self-regulation will put in these recommendations. That's, you don't need to bother setting down laws. We'll just, we'll self-regulate all the file that the suggestions they make are only a fraction of what's needed and they've no intention to go through them anyway. That is what it seems to me as just another sort of version of that as you're right. I mean, very few companies are going to opt in it, which means it's, it's kind of pointless. The only option you've got is to try and manually do it by, what it's disabled and third party cookies and have them go through the various hoops to protect yourself because no one's going to protect you for you. No, definitely not. And to be honest, if you're a half-savvy tech user, then it's not really that difficult to do. But it's one people, I feel sorry for people who maybe those intermediate users who, you know, they know how they're going to edit in preferences blah, blah, blah. They probably honestly believe they're actually disabled in it by having this do not track. But it's just one of those things. I mean, Google and Facebook. How much do they charge you for using their services? Monetarily? Nothing. It's not a paid-for-service. They make their money. And they didn't become two of the biggest computer companies by doing things ethically and having absolutely no advertising blah, blah, blah. They are monitoring you ever so closely. It doesn't take much for you to see. Every time you put in a search saying, we recommend this for you. You know, it's the same with Facebook. I remember when I used to actually have a Facebook profile. I would get constant adverts for Linux system administrators. Blah, blah, this. And I was like, oh, this is just getting too annoying. But anyway, I think we've probably finished up on this section. That's just actually a good timing. We've just come up to half-hour. And we are going to play a bit of getting start a bit of rock here. And this is amity and fame. Who had a great band? If you haven't checked, check them out. The first album is on Jemento. And it's called Dinner for One. The second album is available on their website. It's called Through. I have both of those are brilliant. And this track is New Born Sun. Enjoy. I have both of those are missing. I have both of those are missing. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I have both. I bring me some life and less time. I bring some life and less time. I bring some life and less time. I bring some life and less time. I bring some life and less time. I bring some life and less time. It's our time to go down and shine It's our two four and five It's our music, our song And sure to throw out you will see We'll change as fast as you'll be free When you accept to share with me You'll step in in our choir tree We'll change as fast as you'll be free Now thank you for trusting my help Stand in here and I'll know the time Still remember me without my soul You'll love so much within you You'll come at me again, you'll rule You'll come at me again, you'll rule When you accept to share with me You'll step in in our choir tree We'll change as fast as you'll be free And we're back And even the non-take-a-user, especially in the UK this last couple of weeks would have struggled to not notice in the news that a certain franchise that has become quite a regular place on the UK High Street has actually gone into liquidation And this is the store game Now actually I didn't know this but game is also owned Also owns the company I thought was a driver as game station So they're actually one and the same So now this does obviously mean there's a lot of potential redundancies They haven't closed all their stores yet They did actually close some very quickly But they haven't closed them all yet This will leave obviously in a bad climate a lot of people at a work But that's not really the angle we're going to look at We want to actually just discuss tonight how in fact game made its end So do you want to start off with that? I've not been a gamer for a while But when I was a game was one of the regular places you were going and looking and seeing new releases and sometimes buy stuff But game had a lot of issues And it seems to be quite a common experience from people all over the country And game stores where you go in and they've got a bossate of basically bouncing on people and trying to sell you stuff And game, I mean that, that irritates me no end and at any store in regard to what it is My bossate is if I want help I'll ask for it And I don't want someone to sort of pounce on it On me as soon as I come in the door But game always do that They've got to do it as part of their stuff policy So I mean the thing is with gamers As chances are most people who go into these to buy games know what and stuff they like They are the people that are going to be experiencing it And they are the people who are going to be playing the games And they are the people who are going to have either played the game at their mates house Or they've played demos of it Or they've seen reviews And they'd basically know what type of thing they're looking for They know what type of I mean for a while THC were absolutely awful Anything they had was terrible, terrible games And people know what they want They don't need anyone to help sell them stuff But game never quite grasped that concept Yeah I was back in my windows days I was a big user of games as well Obviously one of the things that it's a bit disappointing with Linux Really the game scene hasn't caused up Well it's getting a lot better I must admit this mission last year and a bit that it was But I remember going into game I've been into game once inside became a Linux user And I mean talk about the customer who was right She was not on the policy this day Because I just thought well I wondered if they do actually have any I didn't expect there to be a full section of Linux games I'd be realistic But I thought well they had a game store Let's see if they've got any native Linux games at all To see if they might have the odd one or two And I thought well if they do even if they're crap games I'll buy them just purely to show you know to show up and to support for them And I went and asked I said do you have any games that are native for Linux? The first guy asked on the till He said what's Linux? What's that? Is it a new console? I'm not going on my word And the other guy He said reaction was iconology What he said was why would we? Linux is a pile of crap Well needless to say I never went into a game since then So this doesn't make me sad to see game disappearing At least one of the things I have found with local game stores Not so much the game chain but localised ones They will actually at least accommodate you And a lot of them will say well we can try and get some in If you can tell us a couple of suppliers or makers But I could not believe how rude that guy was So that was my last experience of game It's not just the condescension And the pouncing on people as well It doesn't work It's the whole value for money I routinely found that game Were rather expensive For the games Unless it was like the grade A, the brand new releases Where they had no choice but to compete Otherwise people would go on the week of a new release If they didn't compete in pre and price People would go to other stores and buy them So they had no choice but other than that Or they were on the expensive side And then they did like pre-owned games as well Which a lot of people now are Because instead of paying like 45 bucks, 50 bucks for a game I think it's going down a little bit now But instead of doing that They're only wait three or four months And then either get it pre-owned or something That half the price But even that when you trade in a game A game there They'll give you peanuts for it And then when they put their pre-owned sticker on It's huge, they put a huge mark upon it So that it's only like two or three bucks cheaper than the brand new one So there's a huge mark up there On stuff that they do They're condescending They jump on people as soon as they come in the door All in all It's a whole recipe for a failing It's a way not to run a business Basically is what games seem to be concentrating in And I think what they were going for As I mean as you said, you were kind of surprised that They owned what youth thought was the rival as well I thought they did, but I was too sure When they go and buy rival chains So that they are the only game, the knowledge basically And they are the only game in a short and a short and a run out of time I think the logic is, we're a monopoly, we get a monopoly That customers will have no choice but to come to us And put up with their bullshit Put up with those pouncing on them when they come in the door Put up with our condescending attitude And put up with our high-prite high-pricees The problem is they are not a monopoly They may be a monopoly as far as independent games Stores are concerned But they're not a monopoly on where people get their games No, definitely not And the other thing that was interesting was To read when you're talking about This was three years ago They were recommended That group was set up because obviously Game have been struggling for a while It's not just for just now They were recommended That in the future, in the next few years That you'd see chirping over from people buying physical games Like in the box and off the shelves To digital downloads And they were actually recommended that they should produce This and they should produce actually a download store And it is also as well I'm just reading this here For using the game brand to Parodigital storefronts on the PC's console It's another platform So in other words, you could maybe get Your game app on the Android phone iPhone or on the PC Something similar to Steam or Dezura But it seems those have been totally ignored And in fact, it said The CEO at the time Was her name Lisa Morgan She actually said That this was completely unnecessary these steps And I mean For some people that are in the technology game Okay, it's gaming But I cannot believe somebody could actually be that blind To say no, no What we're doing, we're going to continue on with Because it's quite obvious People are buying less and less physical games I mean, all you're going to do is Have a wee look at the console industry People are buying less and less And when people are buying games This drives me bananas for one The games are getting shorter and shorter But they're more concerned With getting played over Xbox Live Or whatever the PlayStation equivalent of that Is the PS3 equivalent of that It's more online gaming It's not as much a physical thing It's pain for your download Getting it there and then It's not so much going and getting the box Yeah, I mean, certainly When I was a gamer And I'm talking about the early days of the PS2 And that was at a time Where console gaming Over a network was It was a rare thing You could buy a modem for the PS2 But it was expensive and you It wasn't really as it had on And the Xbox I can't remember The whole network thing Was the The exclusive domain pretty Almost exclusive Of the Windows PC Platform and console games Hadnt went down that way And even as far as Delivering games Buying the games is concerned You couldn't really buy them as A download you would buy them Because they were so big Expensive and it wasn't as widespread For regular consumers Actually buying a game That would take like Two or three gig Was just a not an option A feasible option and people Were happy to buy the discs The problem that I mean this goes to Not just gaming but our All sorts of creative niches as well As if you get the Grade A titles, the top titles You're being hammered By the supermarkets So you buy them in and buy the top Ten or top 20 games Top 20 books, DVDs, Blu-rays, whatever it is The stuff that's charting The stuff that's being push Really heavily And expected to sell By the bucket load And the weeks and months And it comes out They are buying them in so much bulk So if you go to something If your new game comes out You may be able to try it And play it in a game to have a quick Game of it to see what it's like But it may be ten quid more expensive There than saying That's fine and over it's like now I'll go to Tesco and buy it And I'll go to Safeway and buy it So they've been undercut over there As far as the regular games are concerned Only niche they've got then Becomes the more obscure stuff Not being Other back catalogs Because the supermarkets Buy and bulk and expect to sell It through and bulk And as soon as it Tips below a certain sales point As soon as it goes out the charts They send them all back And you can't buy them They had only place you've got Is the independent places like Game So that was the physical thing Someone who was in charge of a company And presumably Very well paid For that role And presumably taking out Wards of millions of pounds and bonuses For doing such a bang up job To not see that the future Was online that is That is, that is I can criminal as far as Shareholders are concerned That's obvious I mean, you don't need hindsight And online and getting your content online And download it And you know, that is That is today, that has been today for a while now And it's just, it's crazy They didn't see that coming I mean, okay, you could say Well, we see it coming, we don't know The like it, but we have to adapt Somehow, and at least have a goal Try and you adapt it We've fighting the fight But to just stand up and say, oh no, we don't want that It's just sticking your head in the sand It's like legacy industry We don't want to adapt To the way the customer wants Because it's not as much profit in it for us We would rather force people To do it our way When they clearly don't want to Like I said, I can't get over this from my head It sounds like actually The company was being run by somebody Who wasn't tech savvy at all Which, you know, it baffles me It really does I just cannot get my head around how anybody You know, maybe, okay, 15 years ago if they had said Well, we don't want to go in that And then, you know, five years ago Saying, well, you know, I think it's time We started moving Even that would have been more acceptable But we're talking three years ago here We're not talking a long time ago I mean, my first broadband connection Was when 2001 It was 2001 It was the first time I had broadband So, I mean, we're talking It's eight years after broadband was regular into homes I mean, I wasn't the first to get broadband I had to kind of wait until I got afforded Because it was quite pricey first of all So, we're talking about eight years after It was the norm in homes And this person And that's, I mean, Xbox Live And all that must have been out by then I mean, how could there be That blinker To say, okay How could anybody be so blind As to think, no, this is just a passing fad People are going to want to come in I mean, not even With the, just the case of the download But even if you want to think about it from the What, you know, going green has been very, very much on people's agenda Recently, a lot more than this been You know, so you're talking, well, there's no physical Plenty in there, there's no delivery, there's no You know, CO2 might You know, so you're talking Well, there's no physical Plenty in there, there's no delivery, there's no Ty ojos, there's no packaging to dispose of There's no treatment actual Shopped to go get it You know, I just don't get the The blinker'sness of the Continuous, I mean hills There's no packaging to dispose of There's no script to go get it You know, so guy. You know, I mean, it just seems it was just an utter disaster. I think I would be if I was a shareholder, I would want to be going after this day for that for being so short-sighted and making so many wrong decisions. And usually when it comes to legacy businesses, they don't want to risk anything that might just be an marginal case or an outside horse coming up on the side and sort of breaking through the norm. They don't want to risk that, especially if it cannibalises their current thing and they're really resistant to adopt anything new. But there's two words here that you cannot ignore. You've got iTunes and Steam. I've never used either. But as far as I'm aware, both iTunes and Steam are household names, the world over. PC gamers, Windows PC gamers, should I say, they love Steam. They use Steam. There might not be much of an alternative. I don't know. But Steam is a household name where it's a platform and people go and then sign up with their credit card and whatever and download games and demos and add-ons for games and all that. It's a platform to get games onto the front of the machine. And then iTunes, backed by Apple, created by Apple, where you can have, you can buy music, you can buy videos and whatever else they do and have them syncing across to your different devices. They have both been major mainstream services for a long time now. They are major mainstream brands. They are Apple, certainly. They're not one of the richest or most profitable companies on the planet with more cash than fucking God. If they don't have a successful strategy. And that's what it is. They've proven. They've proven, along with the Steam, that this is the present. This is what people are expecting. And even taking the whole and the app store model as well, that's the same thing. People are now used to that. And that's nothing new. So for someone to sort of see these major mainstream things, and still not get it, it's just as clueless. Basically, it's like Frank's side bottom running the company. But even not getting the future or not getting the present, even, it's not even the future. It's the present about how people want to consume content, download TV shows to their stream them to their tablets and the phones and stuff. It's not just that. The other thing they had, when they tried to get into the monopoly thing, the monopoly angle of we own all of the independent retail of all game stores. You see plenty of examples of this where you've got like three game stores on the same street. And all of them have worked on a long-term leases for the high street. And they're all competing with each other. And all three of them are wasting money on a long-term rents and playing staff and paying insurance and all this. So they're basically hemorrhaging money because they've got too many stores, basically. The one thing that you see me raise a good point there. But the one thing I've just thought about is people do want the physical. This is one, you talk about iTunes as well. I don't know why, but it's the one area where the music is an advantage over gaming. With music, people do still like to have physical. I mean, I must admit, I love to get us a CD by a CD or for band and support them. Or as recently actually I bought an LP. But gaming's never had that. Not as far as to my knowledge. Okay, you will get some people. I mean, I remember back in the days of the big box games. I mean, those boxes came out. There were like two VCR videos put together. I'm just video tapes put together. They were huge. And you did get some people who, when they released them as DVD style covers, they were saying, oh no, I like the big box games. You did get some people like that. But overall, the gaming industry does not get people with that kind of nostalgic thing with a coin. I mean, you still do get an awful lot of people, like I said, buying the physical versions of music. But that has never ever translated to gaming. Not 100% sure why, but maybe it's just the gamers just adapt quicker. Maybe just wouldn't be probably more in the lines of cutting-edge technology. Maybe we just don't have nostalgia. I remember nostalgia to us. Maybe it might be downloading the ROMs in the 8-minute for the Atari 2600. I'm not 100% sure. But that is one place where gaming does not work. So I mean, yes, you could say, well, why do we still have music stores? But I think they are feasible. They do work. And as you can see now on the high street, well, not new to the high street, but certainly off the side streets. There are more and more independent kind of record. I mean, when I say record, I mean, LP shops, springing up. I don't think whatever going to get that sadly with the gaming industry at all. I mean, I remember back when I started gaming. And when I first started gaming, it was the old Sinclair spectrum. I just love going to the gaming shops and used to see wall-to-wall tapes. Most of them would screech for 15 minutes and then crash and you'd have to rewind them and play them again. But that's not the point. I sadly, I do see that the traditional computer gaming store, especially the independent one. I always like the independent ones. That is a dying breed now, sadly. I don't think we're going to see them at very much longer. Because of, well, I mean, obviously there's a reason for it because the likes of Steam, online gaming, when you look at one of the most popular games for current market just now is Minecraft. There is no physical copy of it, not a legal one in it, as far as I know. Now, well, first off there, I had a point and then I'll come back to that. But on the second thing you were talking about, about the independence, actually, I don't know if you could really call game independent, to be honest. It is a chain store. There's so many stores all across the the Lincoln Bridge of the country that they are a chain store and they're not independent, really. No, no, I was actually talking about the independent gaming stores. As a member of those wee computer shops, they might have been called, well, there was two here called these store and we're computer shop. There was one I used to visit and in Venice, just used to be across from the back door of the Cali Hotel and it was called the Inverness Computer. That's the kind of ones I'm talking about. There's a lot of these levels. No, no, I agree with you there, totally. Game itself was a chain and it was a blooming big chain. I know, I mean, to be honest, the two shops you were talking about there were part of the D chain. No, I know what you mean. I'm just saying that I think we'd probably wrongly been talking about game as independent. I'll just start to mention that. But the thing is, there's really, there's always going to be a place for truly independent sellers of things like games and books and movies and audio and all of that. Question is whether it can survive as a physical thing or not, or whether it really would need to be online. Because the one thing that the big stores, as I said earlier, that the one thing they can't do is offer a wide selection of stuff. I mean, you go into an HMB store and you're looking for some artist's back catalog and you see some album that was out in 1974 and it kind of didn't excel that way on. It's almost been on the brink of being deletive, being deletive of the catalog, but they still got two copies sort of thing. There's always that niche and there's always the value and the staff there having knowledge of that and being able to say, oh, we've got almost a collector's thing. There's always going to be a value in that, but whether it's going to be a value or profit or there was a physical store as another case, likely not. So these independence, there's always value in that. But back to what originally was going to say this, but was people are buying something that's different from what's on sale. When companies sell, I mean, say it's EA games, when they sell FIFA, they're selling it as they're putting, they're telling you the value is in this and this game, you know, in this desk and in this box and you've got the only booklet and stuff like that with all the moves and stuff like that. That's not what people buy. The people buy something to put in their machine and get the controller in their hand and the value is in the experience they have by looking at the screen and pressing the buttons and getting scoring goals and setting up goals and stuff like that. And most games, if not all games now, you have training levels where it says if it's like a first person showing your press squared to docking. So you've got in-game training and a lot of people are familiar pretty much with different genres of games anyway. So you can jump into a football game and okay, the person, the shoot button might be swattering about, but it doesn't take you that long to figure that one out and you can learn on the go. And I mean, for the point is you don't pick up the, when you back a game, what, I mean, when was the last time you bought a game and said, right, I better read the instructions first. You don't do that, you just put the thing in the machine, you switch it on, the controller on your hand and you play. So that's, there's no, there's little to no value in the actual, the medium, the physical medium, the disc and the Emily card in the box other than to keep it safe and unscratched on a shelf. It's the same with that, with a movie, if you buy a blu-ray or a DVD, you don't get any value from the physical disc. You put the disc in the machine and you've got your remote to press the button and have that movie or that TV show play whenever you want to watch it. And you've got the value is in the extras where you can watch them and see how things were made and influences and things like that and put on director's commentaries. And that's where the value is, it's not in the physical product. You have to be buying a physical product, but you can easily download that as long as the actual quality is the same as what you see on the screen and all the buttons work the same way, it doesn't matter whether that came from a download on your hard drive or whether it came from a disc that you put in the machine, the medium is irrelevant. Yeah, I suppose the only way you say the medium would be irrelevant would be maybe with slightly older users, but this isn't really that much of a gaming issue to be honest. You know, maybe they might not be trusting so much as far as, you know, I want to see if I've paid good money for it, I want my physical copy, but realistically that has got to be a dying breed and the other thing is you'd have to be a pretty old gamer to be of that mentality. And I suppose maybe that's one of the reasons why bookshops are still, you know, they're still fairly regular. Obviously a lot of older people still read, you know, but not so much older people, I can't imagine that many older people will be signing up for the new consoles from Sony and Nintendo, you know, but it's just one of those things. But yeah, there's absolutely as far as I can see that there is almost no benefit these days in doing something like in having the likes of a gaming shop. Why? Well, for a start, you've actually got to employ people to work there, you've got to pay your rates, you've got to pay your rent, you know, you've, you've got to have, I mean, you've got to cover not just enough to make money on the game that you bought, you've then also got to make enough money so to cover all these other things. Now, on top of that, yes, you do have the advantage that you do get someone you're speaking to when you go in and it is local, as far as geographically, it could be local and might part of a huge chain. But I just don't get where the comparison is for like when you can buy it online, where as you said, buy it online, it's maybe 15 quid cheaper, you also get constant updates, you know, if there's an update, if there's updates, there's 1.5 whatever, if you bought that, chances are you'll get it downloaded, if you buy it in store and then there's an update consumption, you've probably got to go on buy the blood thing all over again, you know, there's certainly not going to send it out for free. So to be honest, it really is stacked against them and this is what I think, you know, gaming apart from maybe a small corner and maybe HMV, I think you're always going to have something, some physical because there's plenty too many places where the broadband still isn't reaching and reaching very well. I mean, I still know people are certain parts, even on the island here, I mean, I get a great connection for the island, I'm about seven and a half meg, my connection, but yet I know people are outside of the area, they can't connect to broadband at all, so they use satellite and the maximum speed they'll get one, one MB, you know, so realistically and they're also very much limited and how much they can download. So realistically, it's not an option to download games, you are still going to get those, but the more and more time goes on, the more and more things are upgraded, the more and what it's just going to become a niche. I mean, to be honest, there's probably not that many consoles now that people have that aren't connected to the internet, that aren't getting these updates, that aren't playing with their mates online, rather than physically getting the disk and then phoning up their mates and saying, oh right, could you, do you want to come around play this game? No, I said that'll do the same, right, you know, you fancy, fancy going for a game online, yep, give me two minutes to allow gone and that's just the way of the world and we have to move with it, if we're in the industry, you can't just simply see I'm putting my head in the sand and do absolutely nothing, instead we're going to have to be seeing right, we've got to move with it or we're going to die and sadly the latter has happened, you know, I'm, again, it's no loss to me but at the same time we've got to think we can't just be that blinkered and say tough it's no loss, it's no error lost tough, we are going to, you know, there was a lot of people employed by game, it was a big franchise so but they didn't move with the times and they're paying the price of it now. I mean there's all sorts of advantages and disadvantages for bricks and more of as well as an online thing, I mean some companies can do it where they they have some sort of combination thing whereby you can reserve it online or you can even buy it online and go and pick it up in store, there's people who go in in store to actually, I mean I do this when I'm looking at things and things in like commenting queries, I'll check them out online and I sort of narrow them down and then go into the store and actually see them in the flesh so to speak and assuming there's no price difference between that and online, I might not even buy them there, I might buy them Amazon, so there's that I mean if you're only online then you miss out on that and some people as well is because there's also a sort of companies claiming like first sale rights whereby you cannot transfer the thing that you supposedly quote bot on quote, if you don't have the physical copy, you can't do anything about that, I mean if you go and buy a physical book you can do whatever the fuck you want with that, you can you can give it to your mom, your dad, your son, your daughter, however, you can sell it, you can you can give it to a charity shop, it's a physical item that changes ownership, if you've got an ebook, well that's different you know there's there may well be limits on that through DRM or if you lose a copy of it, if you lose your computer or something and the you know do you have to go and buy it again, are you allowed to make a backup, so there's there's that but yeah I mean there is the idea of the sort of blend on and offline is some companies that have happened to that are there's arm but to avoid the whole online thing altogether that's just insane, as far as the updates are concerned you're right, I mean if you if you get something that's you going to buy it online you will get the latest latest version, might have bug fixes or something like that, but that's just the way it is suppose I mean that the other thing that that went against game as well was they they had pissed off publishers by their pre-owned stuff and because again the first sale thing is that when they sell pre-owned they don't have to give any of that money to to the publishers because the publishers already made their profit on the first sale and I'm the tonne these bastions of free culture publishers decided to retaliate by doing things like refusing to supply AAA titles when they came out, a lot of these big AAA stuff it's like movies the the real value to the retailer comes in their initial week of release that's when most people who want it and who are going to pay fuel price for it are going to buy it and if they are not supplied with it they can't buy it there and so they're going to lose out out there as well so yeah that's that's one thing that's that's also counting against them yes it is all right and are we about ready to wrap this up and just noticing the times are ticking on did we get any more suggestions? Yeah from Phil the bearded gnome who were asked about companies that sell one of our sell pieces without without one without windows sorry to avoid the windows tax so and he's mentioned I've got a company called Cougar Extreme who do that underneath him and so on to that they've been doing a bit of thinking on how the site is going and how it can be improved and how easy to do things basically and what we used to have was separate sections for recommended links to sites like tect up and all that stuff for media for for like podcast and things events like it was them or whatever and I wanted to do all that in a fancy way with sort of lists and all that and it's pretty that's been that's been a wasted time essentially so what I'm decided to do is actually set it up instead I've removed all of that and set it up as a wiki so if you've not got a wiki button it's dripples on internal wiki it's quite limited but it's functional and we're using that now for lists of things like how to avoid the windows tax companies you can you can support and Phil's list is on there we're going to have that for suggestions for topics for criminals as well if you've got topics you want to suggest it does mean you need an account with the the dripple side is the main unseen studio site to do that and then add your own stuff there the other question is the forums are small they are a separate program it's Fox BB and my thinking is given the fact that it's that small and we're shurving most things across onto the wiki anyway and then if the feedback for individual episodes can go in the comments sections for those episodes is there any point in having a forum that's that's the question is there any point in having a forum my my instincts are no it's not but you know that's that's a question of putting out there if anyone has as a compelling reason to keep it keep the forum or to keep the forum as it is or just to do away with it then either side of that debate just please let us know and we'll only think about it so yeah I think that's that's it for that discussion the main thing is I mean if you're feeling no no we really do like the forums then you know let us know with us we don't want to be enraging our listeners at the same time though if you do really want to keep the forums I would really recommend you try and get us any of your mates to listen to this you know whether their real life mates are virtual mates doesn't say it doesn't matter get them signing up and as long as they don't basically their username is not the same as one of we guys dense then we're probably going to be quite happy to assist them however if your spammers would rather not just close the forums or rather close them on top of you so well a big if we're going to flip the birdie to any spammers that are about here I think what it happened actually was it was more that when I was thinking about different eye angles for the site I wasn't aware of existing services that already did that one initially I'd wanted to do logs to list people's when it's user groups and then I realized when I was building the site that there's already a site that specializes in that and they do it so much better as they're the main thing then then we could ever do it as a little site thing so we thought right not going to duplicate that go with that and then I found after that I found that there's also one for events which again is much the same thing let's think it's force events I believe and again that's their whole that's their host host dick and they do it so much better so it's all these little things are building up and I sort of decided look there's no point in having these bits of deadwood on the site you know if there are other places are better for them so yeah they want to wrap this up then wrap this up with all that yeah we're getting there just one last thing I'd like to ask about is just if anybody has an idea for a show or if maybe they're thinking they're like to actually start recording and it's roughly along our kind of guidelines which is just basically it's a free and open source so really all we're really looking for then send an email to the show so that iscrivans at unseenstudio.co.uk and if you want to have a wee discuss about if you fancy becoming part of the unseenstudio's podcast network then you are more than welcome we're hopefully going to keep this expanding out as well you can follow us on identical I am at kevy and garden is at thistleweb we also have one for announcing the shows and that is at unseenstudio and I'm pretty much thinking that says is anything else I've forgotten? yeah that's it we've got also looking for little surreal intro audio clips if you've got something bizarre with the woodcrivans in it it's a little little 30 second clip audio clip then please send and commons at unseenstudio.co.uk and yeah that's it so I want to find the song for the for the end of the show yes and this is actually no I couldn't pronounce his band's name and it's to do like you thought it was to do a Harry Potter song we'll let you do it you far on yeah I hope to try and get mumble to the to the front so that I can read it yeah the band is diddly's diddly's right eye the song has a dreamcatcher and so it's good night from me and it's adios from me yeah don't sugarcoat it's a better pill take it twice a day and it'll make you ill the needle in you're you ragged close so you can see your father mr christopher crow watch but never boils in the in the situation don't go running around crazy aggravation how many numbers can you count to and not pretty hard it's not often I get to talk this long and I intend eat up eat up you were young master the truth is it becoming when you tell me it's some type eat up eat up you were young master and tell us something pretty something pretty before she dies so please excuse me I'm kind of new just show me the ropes and I will tie up you the minute shield that can freeze our tongue so you could never tell me what the hell was wrong I want to kiss you then break up the makeup watch rinse repeat until your conscience is clean and you're able to see you love me how many numbers can you count to and not pretty hard it's not often I get to talk this long and I intend eat up eat up you were young master the truth is it becoming when you tell me it's some type eat up eat up you were young master and tell us something pretty something pretty before she dies you can't just think it says couldn't be anymore you can't just think it says couldn't be anymore you can't just think it says couldn't be anymore you can't just think it says couldn't be anymore eat up eat up you were young master the truth is it becoming when you tell me it's some type eat up eat up you were young master and tell us something pretty something pretty before she dies because I'm a dream catcher I'll take it faster and faster faster you have been listening to Hacker Public Radio or Hacker Public Radio those are we are a community podcast network that releases shows every weekday Monday through Friday today's show like all our shows was contributed by a HBR listener like yourself if you ever consider recording a podcast then visit our website to find out how easy it really is Hacker Public Radio was founded by the digital dog pound and the computer cloud HBR is funded by the binary revolution at binref.com all binref projects are crowd-responsive by linear pages from shared hosting to custom private clouds go to lunar pages .com for all your hosting needs unless otherwise stasis today's show is released under a creative commons attribution share a like the does our license